Showing posts with label uprising. Show all posts
Showing posts with label uprising. Show all posts

Sunday, February 6, 2011

Some major domestic highlights for Feb 5, and what they might mean

  • Protests continued for a twelfth day. A Christian Mass is announced for Tahrir on Sunday. Protests also planned for next week. Protesters in Tahrir Square and elsewhere throughout Egypt appeared to intensify their calls and resolve for the president's resignation, which in their opinion would open the way for complete and meaningful change. Some government employees broke ranks to join the protesters.
  • State television announces resignation of ruling NDP party leadership, including president's son. But many people still are not placated. 
  • Reportedly two minor opposition parties broke ranks with the opposition and began discussions with the government. A third group, the Muslim Brotherhood, also reportedly began to seek talks with VP Suleiman, after initially setting down the president's resignation as a precondition for its involvement. The rest of the opposition seems to stand behind the protest movement's demand that President Mubarak resign as a precondition for talks and a transitional phase. VP Suleiman has said the government is inviting opposition groups for an immediate dialog on constitutional reform. Meanwhile, a self-appointed Committee of Wise Men surfaced to talk with VP Suleiman to explore solutions to the standoff and impasse. But this group seems unconnected to the protest movement as there appears to have been no communication between them and the protesters. 
  • The army began to move tanks near Tahrir and apparently sought to take down the barricades set up by protesters. Protesters moved in as human shields. Later they appeared to take moves to close off one end of the square. There are still pronunciations of fraternity between army units and demonstrators throughout Egypt, and local observers have dismissed any potential for a showdown between the people and the armed forces.     
  • A military commander for the district comprising Tahrir urges the protests to end demonstrations, appealing to nationalist sentiments and saying that foreign intervention was behind the protest movement. Chants of "the Army and the People are one" and "Mubarak must go" erupted, prompting the commander to leave the square.   
  • There are concerns that heavy-handedness will resume, with reported redeployments of plain-clothed police to the streets to round up protesters. There are also concerns on the whereabouts of Egyptian human rights activists 
  • Some normality has been restored to Egypt, with the resumption of some businesses. Government announced banks would operate for a few hours on Sunday.   
  • VP Suleiman's motorcade was caught between gunfire, but Government denies it was an assassination attempt and claims it was a stray bullet. Suleiman was left unscathed. 


-----------

Based on these new developments for Saturday, Feb 5, it is very clear that the standoff/impasse has not yet lost its steam or energy. 

The government is struggling to hold on in its confrontation with the protest masses. It may still want to play a major role in molding what dynamics will emerge next. Various overtures were announced, all being not insignificant. Simultaneously attempts are being made to paint the embattled government and its plight in nationalistic rhetoric. Dynamics of the day also point to the emergence of what may be a strategy to create or exploit disunity among opposition elements. The regime possibly signals through these actions that it is not quite ready to throw the towel.  

A desire is among the Egyptian population for a sense of normality. Various segments, however, differ about approach. Concerned about chaos, some segments are conciliatory towards Mubarak finishing out the remainder of his term. Yet the protesters are still backed by many other segments of the population. Protesters remain determined to engage in the tug-of-war with the regime until their main demand of resignation is met. They also repeated declarations on a new awakening of Egypt that has brought the nation together in a new alert consciousness which remains distrustful towards the regime.      

The top cadres of the Army perhaps are beginning to lose patience with the standoff/impasse, but still seem to be on thin tightrope while they seek to hold together their apparent coolness and firmness. The army still has protected protesters thus far. But some actions on Saturday indicate a testy relationship between the two that could dramatically change the trajectory and scope of developments in the near future.    

All of this makes for a situation that is still very highly volatile, and one that is uncertain in which direction the pendulum will ultimately swing. The atmosphere may take a turn for the worse if a miscalculation is made or an unmeasured response/ initiative is taken.

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

Tunisia's "Jasmine Revolution": Regional (and Broader) Implications?

Within the past month, Tunisia has witnessed a large popular uprising culminating in and galvanized by familiarly recognizable protests over poor economic prospects/conditions and the heavy-handed regime-sanctioned crackdowns on the street.  Called the "Jasmine Revolution" the nearly-month-long uprising is particularly significant in the high speed, and especially in the civilian source of its projection [although this assumption that the final blow was dealt by popular pressure has now been disputed], with which intense drama has unfolded.  At any rate, what we have witnessed is nothing short of remarkable.  

The MENA (Middle East and North Africa region) has witnessed several revolts, protests, coups, insurrections, and wars challenging regimes and status-quo environments even in the post-colonial era.  Yet such past challenges, despite the varying circumstances in which they were born, have almost uniformly yielded little.  The most significantly emerging fruit here has, as many commentators will have undoubtedly pointed out, often been merely changes of names.  That, at most, touted changes have been often suspected of carrying the stitching marks of elaborate cosmetic surgeries: that wounds---old and new---have been repackaged hastily without regard to considerations over fully healing.  

In contrast to this, the recent and continuing Tunisian dynamics brings to focus serious questions regarding the sustainability of political systems and economic systems in uncertain times.  At a deeper more specific level, they once again put the spotlight on the wisdom and viability of exercising governmental authority in a repressive and over-aggressive manner (combined with what has been seen as periodic crumbs and general widespread official apathy), in the region.  Leaders, pundits, and officials are quick to either proclaim or dismiss the possibility of the "Tunisian Scenario" on the airwaves, in blogs, and on social media sites.  In trying to get a hold over understanding the seemingly dizzying weeks, I present in no particular sequence a list of news articles and op-eds that put Tunisia's events in the broader regional contexts (not a completely exhaustive list, but one that can hopefully be sufficiently representative).  Of course, much more information and analysis will be available in the days and weeks to come ...    

[Note: a temporary caretaker cabinet has been set up to organize elections, stabilize the country, and to implement reforms and head inquiry commissions over corruption and Ben Ali's regime's response to the protests.  But the retention of Ben Ali officials for the Prime Minister, Foreign Minister, and Interior Minister (responsible for internal security) posts in the new 'unity government' has left many Tunisians skeptical and angry.  A fresh round of protests has been reported, along with the resignation of 3 independent members of the cabinet, barely a day after the new cabinet announcement.]  

  1. Could other Arab countries follow Tunisia's example? Roger Hardy, BBC

  2. No sign Egypt will take the Tunisian road. John Leyne, BBC; another view/angle

  3. Tunisia unrest a wake-up call for the region. Ian Black, The Guardian

  4. Tunisia's protests spark suicides in Algeria and fears throughout the Arab world. Ian Black, The  
  GuardianThe Arab world's horrific new trend: self-immolation. Blake Hounshell. Foreign Policy 
  Passport. (blog); new additional reported attempts here

  5. The 'bin Laden' of marginalisation: the real terror eating at the Arab world is the socio-economic 
  marginalisation. Larbi Sadiki, Al Jazeera English

  6. Tunisia protests serve warning to autocratic Middle Eastern regimes. Kristen Chick. The Christian
  Science Monitor


  7. To the tyrants of the Arab world ... Lamis Andoni, Al Jazeera English 

  8. Arab regimes on edge. Marc Lynch. Foreign Policy. blog


  9. Two views/angles of U.S. comprehension of, and response to, Tunisia (1,2)

  10. People power succeed without Western backing. Emad Mekay, Inter Press Service (Johannesburg); 
  another view/angle.

  11. Unrest spreads to Algeria. Emad Mekay, Inter Press Service (Johannesburg).

  12. Arab bloggers cheer on Tunisia's Revolution. Robert Mackey. THE LEDEThe New York Times
  (blog)

  13. Kenya should draw lessons from the goings-on in Tunisia. Daily Nation. (Nairobi). [Not a part of 
  the MENA obviously, but an article like this reveals that people are feeling the reverberations far from 
  Tunisia and are reflecting on them.]