Tunisia's "Jasmine Revolution": Regional (and Broader) Implications?

Within the past month, Tunisia has witnessed a large popular uprising culminating in and galvanized by familiarly recognizable protests over poor economic prospects/conditions and the heavy-handed regime-sanctioned crackdowns on the street.  Called the "Jasmine Revolution" the nearly-month-long uprising is particularly significant in the high speed, and especially in the civilian source of its projection [although this assumption that the final blow was dealt by popular pressure has now been disputed], with which intense drama has unfolded.  At any rate, what we have witnessed is nothing short of remarkable.  

The MENA (Middle East and North Africa region) has witnessed several revolts, protests, coups, insurrections, and wars challenging regimes and status-quo environments even in the post-colonial era.  Yet such past challenges, despite the varying circumstances in which they were born, have almost uniformly yielded little.  The most significantly emerging fruit here has, as many commentators will have undoubtedly pointed out, often been merely changes of names.  That, at most, touted changes have been often suspected of carrying the stitching marks of elaborate cosmetic surgeries: that wounds---old and new---have been repackaged hastily without regard to considerations over fully healing.  

In contrast to this, the recent and continuing Tunisian dynamics brings to focus serious questions regarding the sustainability of political systems and economic systems in uncertain times.  At a deeper more specific level, they once again put the spotlight on the wisdom and viability of exercising governmental authority in a repressive and over-aggressive manner (combined with what has been seen as periodic crumbs and general widespread official apathy), in the region.  Leaders, pundits, and officials are quick to either proclaim or dismiss the possibility of the "Tunisian Scenario" on the airwaves, in blogs, and on social media sites.  In trying to get a hold over understanding the seemingly dizzying weeks, I present in no particular sequence a list of news articles and op-eds that put Tunisia's events in the broader regional contexts (not a completely exhaustive list, but one that can hopefully be sufficiently representative).  Of course, much more information and analysis will be available in the days and weeks to come ...    

[Note: a temporary caretaker cabinet has been set up to organize elections, stabilize the country, and to implement reforms and head inquiry commissions over corruption and Ben Ali's regime's response to the protests.  But the retention of Ben Ali officials for the Prime Minister, Foreign Minister, and Interior Minister (responsible for internal security) posts in the new 'unity government' has left many Tunisians skeptical and angry.  A fresh round of protests has been reported, along with the resignation of 3 independent members of the cabinet, barely a day after the new cabinet announcement.]  

  1. Could other Arab countries follow Tunisia's example? Roger Hardy, BBC. 

  2. No sign Egypt will take the Tunisian road. John Leyne, BBC; another view/angle. 

  3. Tunisia unrest a wake-up call for the region. Ian Black, The Guardian. 

  4. Tunisia's protests spark suicides in Algeria and fears throughout the Arab world. Ian Black, The  
  Guardian; The Arab world's horrific new trend: self-immolation. Blake Hounshell. Foreign Policy 
  Passport. (blog); new additional reported attempts here. 

  5. The 'bin Laden' of marginalisation: the real terror eating at the Arab world is the socio-economic 
  marginalisation. Larbi Sadiki, Al Jazeera English. 

  6. Tunisia protests serve warning to autocratic Middle Eastern regimes. Kristen Chick. The Christian
  Science Monitor. 


  7. To the tyrants of the Arab world ... Lamis Andoni, Al Jazeera English.  

  8. Arab regimes on edge. Marc Lynch. Foreign Policy. blog. 


  9. Two views/angles of U.S. comprehension of, and response to, Tunisia (1,2)

  10. People power succeed without Western backing. Emad Mekay, Inter Press Service (Johannesburg); 
  another view/angle.

  11. Unrest spreads to Algeria. Emad Mekay, Inter Press Service (Johannesburg).

  12. Arab bloggers cheer on Tunisia's Revolution. Robert Mackey. THE LEDE. The New York Times. 
  (blog)

  13. Kenya should draw lessons from the goings-on in Tunisia. Daily Nation. (Nairobi). [Not a part of 
  the MENA obviously, but an article like this reveals that people are feeling the reverberations far from 
  Tunisia and are reflecting on them.] 

Economics, and an Online Game on Recycling

How much can we learn about economics, indeed about our own selves, from recycling, and about the choices we have to make on a daily basis individually and collectively? Let's start answering this question by exploring some of the most basic ideas involved in the academic discipline we call economics.

The science of economics tells us that, at any given point in time, a given resource or factor of production will be scarce. Even in times of 'abundance,' resources and factors of production could be said to be more scarce or less scarce depending upon its supply and upon the availability of technology to extract or modify them for use. This concept of scarcity is central to a fundamental imposition of constraints that we, as societies and individuals, face in how to best manage the resources we are endowed with as well as to how best seek new sources of resources and factors of production. And among the most important of such constraint is what economists have called opportunity cost. 

Due to scarcity, our decisions over how we use, or don't use, a given resource or production factor will impact other decisions over other resources. For example, time is an important resource, and depending upon our preferences, values, and other subjective and non-subjective constraints and circumstances, we may have (at any given instance) the choice to employ this resource in one activity or other. So let's say we have an hour of free non-sleep time left after a busy day: we may choose to spend that hour in leisure (such as watching a TV comedy show), or we may opt to take care of unfinished house chores. Given constraints and circumstances, such as health and physical fatigue, we now have to make the choice on how to spend that specific hour. If we undertake chores, then leisure must be given up, and if leisure is preferred then the opportunity for house chores will be not taken advantage of. Thus the opportunity cost of leisure is not doing chores, the opportunity cost of chores is forsaking leisure.

Because economics is a social, behavioral, and management science, such concepts apply to almost everything in our professional lives in addition to many day-to-day tasks. Recycling programs seek to conserve and maintain the level of resources at a rate that could keep production of goods and services physically sustainable. They also may prove beneficial to businesses and producers in helping to minimize costs (especially in the long run). But, as societies and economies evolve, expand, and become more sophisticated---and as their production possibilities curves (the total combinations of goods/services that can be produced with available production factors, resources, and technology) expand outward (which would imply the development and implementation of greater technology, efficiency, as well as an expansion of resource bases)---constraints, preferences, and circumstances will still be faced; the dilemmas posed by scarcity will not magically go away. This applies even to businesses that have specialized to serve the recycling industry--from garbage collectors to materials reprocessing--as production factors like labor and capital (i.e. vehicles for transporting waste to disposal sites and recyclables to reprocessing sites, procuring machinery used at sites, etc) and their prices will necessarily need to be constantly considered against scarcity, opportunity costs, and other conditions.

To get an idea of some of the decisions that are involved and are measured and employed against these conditions faced by recycling specialists, I would suggest to take a crack at this game . Published as a part of webpage for a documentary on the recycling industry in Egypt (one of the densest nations in Africa and the developing world), the object of the game is to run a typically modest recycling firm in Cairo and to match their industry's efficiency rate of 80% recycling. Of course, you will face constraints like upkeep costs, figuring out how to expand to optimum recycling facilities and capabilities, as well as the opportunity costs of choosing to whether expand operations to another district in the city (when available). Given all the challenges of matching that efficiency rate in a very dense urban environment, with relatively more modest technology than those found and used in the West, I can say that this strategy simulation has been a humbling and enlightening experience for me.